· by Mohammed Mudassir · Selling a home

What It Actually Costs to Sell a Home on Long Island Right Now

Selling a Long Island home usually costs six to ten percent of the sale price once every fee is counted, and most of that number is set before you ever sign a listing agreement.

Think of a home sale like a staircase. Each step, commission, transfer tax, attorney fee, payoff, takes a bite out of what lands in your pocket at the bottom. You can plan for every step if you count them before you climb, instead of finding out at the closing table.

The big number: commission

Agent commission is the largest single cost in a Long Island sale. Listing agent commission on Long Island typically runs 2.5 percent to 3 percent of the sale price, and if you also offer a buyer's agent fee to attract offers, that doubles the percentage taken off the top. On a home near Nassau County's October 2026 single-family median of $871,000, a combined five to six percent commission alone runs into the tens of thousands.

Suffolk sellers are working from a lower base. Suffolk County's single-family median sale price was $733,500 in October 2026, up 4.8 percent from a year earlier, so the dollar cost of commission is smaller even at a similar percentage.

The tax you cannot negotiate away

New York charges a state transfer tax on every sale, and sellers pay it. The rate is two dollars for every five hundred dollars of the sale price, which works out to 0.4 percent, collected when the deed is recorded. On a $700,000 sale that is $2,800, a fixed cost that does not move with negotiation.

If your home sits in one of the five East End towns, East Hampton, Southampton, Shelter Island, Southold or Riverhead, there is a second tax, but the buyer pays this one, not you. The Peconic Bay Region Community Preservation Fund tax was increased from 2 percent to 2.5 percent in East Hampton, Shelter Island, Southampton and Southold starting April 1, 2023, while Riverhead stayed at 2 percent. That tax is a buyer cost worth knowing about during negotiation, even though it never touches your proceeds.

Attorney, payoff, and the rest

New York requires an attorney on every residential closing, and Long Island rates are fairly standard across the market. Most Long Island residential closings run $1,500 to $3,000 in attorney fees, paid at the closing table rather than up front. That is a flat cost regardless of your sale price, so it matters more on smaller sales than larger ones.

Beyond the attorney, expect your remaining mortgage balance to come off the top as a payoff, along with prorated property taxes for the days you owned the home this year. Total seller closing costs on Long Island commonly land between 6 percent and 9 percent of the sale price once commission, attorney fees, transfer tax, and prorations are added together. None of those numbers include whatever you spend preparing the house itself, paint, repairs, a pre-listing inspection.

What to do with this before you list

Run your own numbers against your actual mortgage payoff and your town's tax proration, not a generic percentage. A rough net sheet before you sign anything tells you what actually lands in your account, and it changes how you think about your asking price. Try the net sheet to see where your number lands once the real costs come off.

If you are still deciding whether this is the year to sell, start with what your home is worth today at my home value, and bring your specific questions to /askmuds.

Ask Muds about your town More notes