Home value report

Setauket home value report

Setauket · Suffolk County · prepared by Muds the Realtor · market data as of 2026-09

Your estimated value

A starting range built from Setauket's median price per square foot ($456 for the 3 months through Oct 2026, data from Redfin) and your home's size. Three scenarios, never one false number. The exact figure comes from Muds walking your home.

Sized at square feet.

Want a review of this home?

Muds and Iqra can review recent comparable sales and the property record with you. Leave a cell number or email so Team Muds can respond about this home.

One contact field. This requests a personal reply, not a newsletter subscription. Privacy policy.

Setauket market snapshot

$1,433,000Median sold price (2026-09)
104.4%Sold to list ratio
33Median days on market
5.5Months of inventory
3.97%Value change, 12 months

Market temperature

Buyer's market35Seller's market

A 0 to 100 read of how hot the market is for sellers, computed from real months of inventory. Setauket is a balanced market right now.

Two years of Setauket

Median sold price by month

$1,159,000$775,0002024-112026-10

Median price per square foot by month

$456$2972024-112026-10

Data from Redfin. Medians move with the mix of homes sold each month, so read the direction over time, not any single point.

Month by month

MonthMedian sold priceMedian $/sqft
2026-10$1,159,194$456
2026-09$1,130,000$451
2026-08$991,000$430
2026-07$972,500$399
2026-06$935,000$407
2026-05$940,000$400
2026-04$930,000$413
2026-03$1,000,006$403
2026-02$924,995$400
2026-01$899,990$421
2025-12$937,000$335
2025-11$972,500$325

Most recent twelve months for Setauket, data from Redfin.

Want the real number for your home?

This report is the town. Your home is not the town. Muds pulls the actual comps for your street, checks the town records on your property, and calls you with three scenarios grounded in your home, usually within a day.

A phone or an email is enough. Both fields are never required.

This report is a market based estimate for information only, not an appraisal or an offer. Market data from Redfin and Muds's own records.

Mohammed Mudassir, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson, NYS License 10401395140 · OverSouth Real Estate, 455 Lake Ave, Saint James, NY 11780 · (631) 528-5786

Equal Housing Opportunity. We support and comply with all federal and New York State fair housing laws. Prepared 2026-09 market data, report generated from hellomuds.com/my-home-value.